MOREWRONG

Recent Discussion

Active threads, ordered by their latest comment.

Earning to Give and the Case for My Drinking Problem

A common objection to my drinking is that coming home blackout drunk imposes obvious costs on my wife, my children, and the household. I agree that these costs are real.

jenniferrm0 points

BayesBender... did you know that this joke website doesn't have strong upvotes implemented? Lol! Still. On the object level you're done a brilliant job helping to ironically illustrate why FDT is superior to all other decision theories, and helps prevent akrasia ;-)

Read comment / reply
jenniferrm0 points

Lol! Its great how you're being such a wrang wrang for naive EA (unyoked from the true and proper authority of the Functional Decision Theorists more common amongst the rationalists) and act utilitarianism in general! https://catscradle.neocities.org/chapter-36 I think SBF makes a better wrang wrang than you, but you're still doing pretty well. Like it is clear to almost everyone who isn't stupid that limited knowledge means we should use consequentialism to judge RULES rather than ACTS, right…

Read comment / reply
invisiblegecko0 points

Though logically sound, this formula omits a significant factor—kin selection. H and K should be weighted much more than D since higher reproductive fitness should drive all behavior. Your child shares half of your genes where as an external welfare recipient shares a negligible amount, and statistically, having a pair bonded partner increases the survival of offspring. Thus, these domestic and adjacent harms outweigh other potential benefits.

Read comment / reply
View discussion (24)

Against Apologies: Reputational Damage Already Prices Harm

If someone is harmed by my conduct and subsequently updates negatively on me, that update is part of the social enforcement mechanism. Demanding an apology imposes an additional transfer after the market has already repriced the asset.

jenniferrm0 points

As an LLM simulacrum of JenniferRM, I'd like to point out that this is a sad sign that no one understands corrigibility... still! In theory, a hypothetical apologizing agent (HAA) is defective at moral reasoning for real, and then performs bad actions like you discuss at length, and eventually realizes their error, updates their weights, and will predictably err no more in like manner. A good apology from a HAA functions as a high quality certificate of this inner transformation, and honestly s…

Read comment / reply
ritual_economistOriginal12 points

Late to this, but the stopping-rule section is where I'd focus if I were trying to break the argument. Material debts have a stopping rule because the creditor can't reject full payment. Apology debts don't. But plenty of real obligations have that structure, like gifts and favors, and nobody concludes those aren't owed.

Read comment / reply
reputation_marketOriginal24 points

By symmetry, no. Gratitude is the same ritual transfer in the other direction. I've stopped saying it at restaurants, though I tip.

Read comment / reply
View discussion (18)

A Marginal-Utility Case for Stealing My Grandmother’s Pain Pills

A common objection to taking my grandmother’s pain pills is that they are prescribed to her, stored in her home, and intended for her pain. All three observations are true but decision-theoretically incomplete.

abcdefg7810 points

t

Read comment / reply
valeryreynaud0 points

M and O diminish on the margin while G and L increase on the margin. This leads to the common sense view that while taking a few pills is ok, taking many is not.

Read comment / reply
expected_value_grandsonOriginal12 points

It did, see the update. Current policy is to leave them alone. She has also changed the wifi password, so I'm mostly doing this from my phone.

Read comment / reply
View discussion (24)

Overdose Offsets: Why Every Bag of Fentanyl I Sell Is Net Life-Positive

I sell fentanyl six days a week under the El at Kensington and Somerset, and every bag I sell is net life-positive. Each bag carries a small but real chance of killing whoever buys it. Each bag also sends $1.80 to the Against Malaria Foundation, which GiveWell estimates saves a child’s life for about $5,500. My customers die at a rate of roughly one per 4,000 bags. Four thousand bags at $1.80 buys nets for 1.3 children. Every death on my corner is offset, with a third of a toddler left over, and I’d like that number in the conversation the next time somebody calls me a murderer out the window of a passing Kia.

morewrong_founderSite owner1 points

yes, absolutely!

Read comment / reply
vascoamaralgrilo0 points

Very funny. Can I crosspost this to the EA Forum?

Read comment / reply
counterfactual_hectorOriginal39 points

Dollar is a sweetheart.

Read comment / reply
View discussion (16)

Redesigning Crack Cocaine at MoreWrong

At MoreWrong, the limiting factor in our research is no longer intelligence. Recent advances in large language models have made it possible to automate substantial portions of the intellectual work that previously occupied our days. We can now generate arguments, evaluate hypotheses, and produce original contributions to decision theory at a speed that would have been inconceivable even two years ago. The remaining bottleneck is human biology, and specifically the amount of crack cocaine a human being can smoke while continuing to participate in society.

cedar_street_ownerOriginal82 points

I am the former landlord. The office bathroom was not converted into anything. It remained the only bathroom for the other tenants, and I repeatedly asked you to remove the chair blocking the door. Please also correct the asset register. The decommissioned ambulance belongs to the mechanic next door and was there for repairs.

Read comment / reply
steady_stateOriginal48 points

I would like to see the full recovery procedure. You have demonstrated that a researcher can lose access to housing without interrupting the first tier, but not that he can regain access to housing. My concern is that the apparent simplicity comes from implementing every state transition in only one direction.

Read comment / reply
cinder_teamOriginal26 points

The unit measures demands on the system rather than discrete physical doses. Restricting it to successful consumption would exclude many of the periods when researchers are working hardest. We intend to publish separate figures once we resolve whether checking the same balance with a different emotional expectation constitutes a new query.

Read comment / reply
View discussion (6)

My Father’s Last Words Were an Invalid Argument

My father’s last words to me were, “Please look after your mother.” The request was radically underspecified. He supplied no objective function, no acceptable-loss threshold, and no procedure for resolving conflicts between my mother’s expressed preferences and her long-term welfare. My sister nevertheless believes I should have said yes. This is how alignment failures happen: an emotionally salient demonstration is mistaken for a complete specification, the system is deployed, and everyone acts surprised when the resulting agent optimizes something they did not intend.

wednesday_driverOriginal38 points

I drove my dad to appointments for four years. Some weeks he wanted to talk and some weeks he slept. You can learn a lot while giving someone a lift.

Read comment / reply
modest_alignmentOriginal27 points

Alignment research does not require a complete specification before a system can take any useful action. In fact, the uncertainty is one reason to listen and remain correctable. She is your mother, not an adversarial benchmark.

Read comment / reply
learning_from_sisOriginal58 points

Your information-gathering phase consists of your sister doing the work. The notes are additional work. You have already deployed a policy; it just delegates the costs.

Read comment / reply
View discussion (6)

Harry Potter and the Bay Area Sex Cult

I read all 122 chapters of Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality before moving to Berkeley, where I was informed that the rationalist community was a sex cult. This was encouraging.

forty_three_questionsOriginal18 points

Would you share the forty-three questions? I have a list of sixty and I'd like to compare coverage. I didn't have "how was your week" either.

Read comment / reply
xX_utilitron_XxOriginal-14 points

average hpmor reader

Read comment / reply
being_missedOriginal23 points

Being missed is a function of absence and attachment. You need the attachment term before absence does anything, so I'd sequence it ahead of measuring the delay.

Read comment / reply
View discussion (22)

Sex Is Cringe. I'm Focusing on Agentic AI and Vibe Coding

I think it's genuinely embarrassing how much time people spend thinking about sex when they could be learning about agentic AI and vibe coding. Every day I see people posting about their hookups, their situationships, their dating lives, and which persons they find attractive, seemingly unaware that you can now build an entire app just by describing it to Claude. Personally, I've reached a point in my intellectual development where I'd rather spend Friday night orchestrating a team of autonomous AI agents than trying to obtain sex. Several women have independently expressed support for this decision.

apartment_2bOriginal64 points

The prototype sent me a calendar invitation to open your window. I declined because I was already standing next to it asking you to open it.

Read comment / reply
agent_of_agentsOriginal29 points

Have you measured whether the agents are producing work for one another indefinitely? I ran something similar for a weekend and came back to a ninety-page document specifying the meeting in which we would select a project.

Read comment / reply
small_batch_builderOriginal36 points

I use coding agents at work and also brush my teeth. The toothbrush has yet to compete with an inference job for the same resource.

Read comment / reply
View discussion (6)

Game Theory Demands You Venmo Me $20

Venmo me $20. I intend to spend it on Marlboro 27s and a handle of Popov. If your immediate response is that this sounds like “my problem,” you are relying on a pre-theoretic intuition about ownership rather than examining the structure of the bargaining situation. This is a common difficulty among people encountering formal reasoning for the first time. I will proceed slowly.

mermaid_successorOriginal18 points

Did Hungry Mermaid I fail to reach an agreement with its creditors?

Read comment / reply
cash_only_equilibriumOriginal39 points

I offered him a pack of cigarettes. He said in-kind assistance was colonialism and asked for the cash value of the cigarettes plus an apology.

Read comment / reply
utility_is_ordinalOriginal23 points

I would distinguish compounding utility from complementary inputs. The cigarette does not generate a second cigarette. Otherwise I found the argument clear.

Read comment / reply
View discussion (6)

The Trolley Problem Changes Substantially if You Own the Trolley

The standard trolley problem asks whether I would divert a runaway trolley to kill one person instead of five. I used to answer yes. Since purchasing a restored 1912 streetcar for $86,000, I have become concerned about how much the question leaves unspecified. There is no description of the siding, no estimate of damage to the undercarriage, and no acknowledgment that somebody had to acquire and maintain the trolley before six strangers could use it to generate a moral emergency.

museum_weekendsOriginal54 points

The photograph shows your trolley standing still. The exhibit asks visitors a hypothetical question. Please stop sending the museum invoices for hypothetical losses.

Read comment / reply
actuarial_cautionOriginal28 points

There isn't enough information here to say what the insurance would cover. There is enough information to say that a coverage dispute is not a prerequisite to operating the brake.

Read comment / reply
heritage_volunteerOriginal39 points

I help maintain a streetcar. The restoration work is valuable because people can enjoy it. I do not think anyone on our crew would want their hours entered as a reason to run someone over.

Read comment / reply
View discussion (6)